Lab #3: Population Projections and Scale

In today's lab, you will be computing rates of population change, and using these rates to project the size of future populations and to compute a population doubling time.   In order to compute population change, the first step is to compute the rate of change. This requires having populations for two time periods. These can be any two points in time since the rate of change will be based on the number of years between the two time periods.

Rate of Change: D P = (P t 2/Pt1 – 1)

Percentage Rate of Change: D P = (P t 2/Pt1 – 1) x 100%

D (triangle) is the Greek symbol Delta which means change.

When computing rates of change and population projections, there are 2 key assumptions.   First, the rate of change over 10 years is assumed to be equally divided across each of the 10 years, and second, the population is assumed to continue to grow at the same rate as it has in the past.

For this lab, you will be using the 1990, 2000, 2009, and 2010 census data to compute a 10-year rate of change for the populations of the five boroughs, New York State, and the United States. You will be comparing the differences between the rates of growth between 1990 and 2000 and between 2000 and 2009/2010, and using these rates to project the population into the future.

1. You will be computing rates of change for 1990-2000 and 2000-2009/2010.

2. You will use the 1990-2000 rates to compute geometric and exponential projections of the population to 2010 and  and discuss the relative accuracy of these projections, using the 2009 county estimates and 2010 state and national enumerations. The difference between the projections is the steepness of the curves.  These equations are adaptations of the formulas used to compute compounded interest.  The slope of the curve on a geometric projection is less steep, so it would be a more conservative projection, while the exponential would be the higher projection.  In slower growing areas, there will be very little difference between your results.  The more rapid the rate, the greater the difference.

Geometric Projection: Pt+n = Pt (1 + r)n

Exponential Projection: Pt+n = Pt er*n

Where t = the first time period, n = the number of time periods relative to the number of years in computing the rate of change. For example, 10 years equals one time period. Thus, if you are using 2000 as your starting population for computing 2010, n=1. 2020 will be 2 10-year time periods from 2000.

3. You will use the two sets of rates you have computed to project the populations for 2030 and 2050, one using 2000 as your base population and 1990-2000 for your rate of change, and one using 2009/2010 as your base populations and using 2000-2009/2010  for your rate of change.

4. As mentioned in class and in your textbook, a population's doubling time in the number of years it takes for a population to double, or the number of years that it would take for Pt+n = 2*Pt using the exponential rate of change.  Using algebra to solve for this results in a formula for doubling time that is ln2/r, but r needs to be computed at 1-year rates.  What that means is that if you have computed a rate of change using ten years, divide by 10 to get a 1-year rate, assuming that growth was equally distributed across the ten years.  The natural log of 2 equals .6931.  

An interesting note on doubling time is that a population has to be growing in order to double.  We discussed the low birth rates in a number of European countries. Some of these countries have negative growth rates. Mathematically, the doubling times for such countries cannot be computed. those that are growing, but at extremely slow rates have doubling times in the thousands of years.

Geometric Growth:
The formula for geometric growth is:

Pt+n = Pt (1 + r)n

Where:

1. Pt+n is the year you are initially projecting to, in this case, 2010; and

2. Pt is the ending point for computing the rate of change, in this case, 2000; and

3. r is the rate of change computed above; and

4. n=the number of time periods you are projecting forward.

In this case, you have computed a ten-year rate of change and are computing a projection for 10 years later, so n=1. If you were using the same rate of change (1990-2000) to compute a projected population for 2030, n would equal 3 (3 ten-year time periods).

"n" is an exponent. That means whatever number is in the parentheses is multiplied by itself "n" times. If n=1, then the value of 1+r is raised to the first power. If n=2 (if computing a projection for 2020), then the value of 1+r would be raised to the second power or squared.

In Excel, exponents are computed using ^. Remember, all formulas are computed from the inside out and must be inputted into the computer from the inside out.


Exponential Growth:
Exponential growth is a bit more complex because it uses "e." "e" is a constant with a value of approximately 2.71828. The formula for computing exponential growth is:

Pt+n = Pt er*n

Again where

1. Pt+n is the year you are projecting to, in this case, 2010; and

2. Pt is the ending point for computing the rate of change, in this case, 2000; and

3. r is the rate of change computed above; and

4. n=the number of time periods you are projecting forward.

When computing regular (base 10) exponents in Excel, you use ^ as described above for geometric growth. When using "e", you use the command =EXP( ).

For this assignment:

Create tables that include the following for the regions listed above:

Populations 1990, 2000, 2009/2010
Rates of Change 1990-2000; 2000-2009/2010
Geometric and Exponential Projections for 2010 using the 1990-2000 rate of change, with comparison to the enumerated and estimated populations
Geometric Projections for 2030 and 2050 using each of the rates
Exponential Projections for 2030 and 2050 using each of the rates
Doubling Time using each of the rates
 

Write a 2-3 page essay discussing your observations. Be sure to address the following topics: strengths and weaknesses of the assumptions based on your computations; how the points in time you choose for computing rates of change affect your projections; and how the geographic scale of the analysis affects your results.

Obtaining your data:

Using "Legacy" Factfinder and the same steps you used for Lab 2, obtain P001 for 1990 and P1 for 2000 for the United States, New York State, and the five boroughs. The boroughs are counties: Bronx, Kings (Brooklyn), New York (Manhattan and Roosevelt Island), Queens, and Richmond (Staten Island).

Copy and paste the 1990 and 2000 data into the same spreadsheet.

Download Lab 3 2010_2009 spreadsheet from Course Materials in Blackboard. This file has the 2010 national and state enumerated populations and the 2009 ACS estimates for the counties. The 2010 county populations haven't been released yet.

By this point, you should have a handle on Excel basics. We will walk through in lab how to convert each of the equations into "Excel-speak." If you get stuck, remember that the step-by-step for obtaining data is in Lab 2.

It is likely you will be making a number of tables for this lab. If you create one table for each step of the analysis, it will be easier for you to write your paper.